Industry Insight, Resource

When Do You Need a Traditional Publishing Deal?

Frances Katz
Frances Katz on May 8, 2018

A Nashville music publisher says she hears the words “I want a publishing deal” more often than “Let’s grab some coffee.” A traditional music publishing deal might seem glamorous to new songwriters, but when do you really need one and do you need one to manage the business side of your career? The answer might actually be no, or at least not straight away. In fact, many top music publishers say they’d rather work with writers who already understand how the business works, and their favorite clients bring them industry knowledge and experience along with great songs.

New songwriters aiming for a career in music can get their feet wet in the industry by working with a publishing administrator before looking for a traditional publishing deal. With a publishing admin, it’s possible to manage your own career, keep all the rights to your songs and collect all your royalties from all sources - domestic, international, mechanical and performance, without giving away your copyright or tying yourself down to a long term contract early in your career.


Traditional Music Publishing Pros and Cons

A traditional publishing deal has risks as well as rewards. A good traditional music publisher will promote your songs, collect your royalties, arrange licensing agreements and in most cases even front you an advance against future royalties. However, their services are not free: they do all this in exchange for a percentage of your royalties - usually somewhere between 25 and 50 percent. They could potentially retain this ownership for the life of your copyright, even after your deal with the publisher has been terminated.

Another important risk to consider: While the idea of signing with a well-known publisher and getting an advance to help with the rent while you build your career seems tempting, an advance is not free money and it is not a salary. It’s a loan. You won’t receive any additional royalties from your song until it’s earned enough to cover the amount of the advance.

The Admin Difference: You Make The Decisions

Instead of taking a lifetime interest in your copyright, publishing administrators charge only a percentage of the money they collect on your behalf, usually about 15 percent. A publishing admin will register your songs with performing rights organizations (aka PROs), mechanical collection societies, and royalty administrators all over the world They’ll also collect royalties from international, mechanical and sync licenses.

When you sign with a publishing administrator, you retain 100 percent ownership of your copyrights. When you sign with a traditional publisher, they own a percentage of all your songs - even songs you haven’t written yet - for a certain period of time, and potentially in perpetuity. When you choose a publishing admin, you may register all of your songs, some of your songs or just one song. New songwriters might choose to register all of their songs with one administrator, while others hire admins in different territories to help them collect international royalties their PRO might have missed.

Publishing Admins Offer Frequent Payments and Flexible Terms

Publishing administrators like Songtrust pay songwriters four times per year, while a traditional music publisher typically pays only twice a year. Working with a publishing administrator makes sure you are paid regularly and quickly with easy to understand royalty statements.

When you sign with a traditional publishing company, you usually sign a multi-year contract with a number of options for renewal. With each option your publisher can evaluate how things are going and either exercise the option to renew your contract or drop you. You may also be subject to a minimum delivery commitment, or a minimum delivery release commitment, meaning you have to deliver a certain number of songs that are released before you can get out of your deal. With a publishing administrator, you agree only to a term with no strings attached.

A traditional publishing deal isn’t right for every songwriter, or can make more sense at different times in your career. Managing your own career with the help of a publishing administrator is a good way for songwriters to manage the business side of their careers and gain some leverage and experience the top music publishers like to see in promising potential clients.

chartWe fully support any of our clients when they decide to move on to a traditional publishing deal, which is why we offer such flexible terms. Until you're ready to sign with a traditional publishing deal, sign up for Songtrust to collect all your global royalties. 

Related Articles

The World of Music Publishing Royalties: Webinar Recap

Throughout November and December, we held a webinar series revolving around The World of Music Publishing Royalties. Over the course of five sessions, hosted by Songtrust's own Noelle Gambuti and Elizabeth McBride, Publishing Specialists, and various special guests, we dove into the major themes of music publishing royalties. We covered topics from the types of royalties your song can earn you to specialized royalties like YouTube and streaming royalties. The turnout was tremendous and those that attended asked a lot of excellent questions.

Dec 13, 2018

How to Get The Most Out of Your Soundcloud Account

Soundcloud has become a critical tool for any songwriter or musician who wants to reach an audience of potential fans – but it isn’t as easy to do as simply pushing a button. As the largest online music community, Soundcloud affords an independent music maker a significant platform, but one that’s crowded with thousands and thousands of other artists, too. Here are some important steps to keep in mind when using Soundcloud to make sure your work stands out and finds the receptive audience you want.

Dec 11, 2018

Retirement Planning for Songwriters

As a songwriter, retirement isn’t exactly at the forefront of your mind - finishing your song, setting up that next gig, and getting new equipment is more likely. However, retirement is ultimately still a top financial goal that you should be working toward.

While it may be the furthest goal out, any good financial plan starts with calculating how much money you’ll need to live on during your retirement years (aka your golden years), putting a strategy in place to get there, and then addressing your shorter-term needs, like upgrading your equipment or booking studio space. Many financial professionals believe you’ll need approximately 80 percent of your peak pre-retirement income to maintain your current lifestyle in retirement - seems like a lot right?

Dec 4, 2018